I have probably sold 15 of these. This is the nicest I have ever had. Not perfect, but REAL pretty. All the hinges are absolutely tight, with no the slightest cracking. The spine & labels are bright & clean as when new. There is a blotch on the front cover, which would likely disappear with leather treatment. Absolutely minimal spalling of the leather, which happens so easily with this type of calf. A few minor scuff marks on the upper outer edge of the rear cover. The only defect, is a loose page. The center page of a signature about half way through the book is loose. However, the book is so tight (it feels unopened), I have not attempted to open it sufficiently to glue it into place. ; 6 1/2x9 1/2"